Dear Deptford Township,

Dear Custodian of Records:

I write regarding your response to my OPRA request seeking Police Reports 25‑046215 and 26‑003952, associated CAD/dispatch records, and all Body Worn Camera footage from P.O. Anthony Casella, Badge #5289, related to the November 9, 2025 incident.

Your response “partially denied” the request, stating that the 2025 and 2026 reports are excluded to protect victim identity and psychiatric calls, and then closed the inquiry. However:

Your agency previously released the full 2025 police report and CAD logs in response to an earlier OPRA request concerning the same incident, demonstrating that these records (with any necessary redactions) are not categorically exempt.

OPRA requires a records custodian to redact exempt information (such as specific victim‑identifying information or confidential medical/psychiatric details) and produce the non‑exempt portions of a record, rather than withhold entire reports.

Your response did not address my specific request for all Body Worn Camera footage from Officer Casella related to report 25‑046215. OPRA requires that you either provide the footage or state the precise statutory basis and subsection for any claimed exemption and, if applicable, whether any BWC‑specific exemption is being invoked.

Any denial or partial denial must identify the legal basis for withholding records and advise the requestor of their right to challenge the denial before the Government Records Council or in Superior Court.

Accordingly, I respectfully request that you:

Reconsider the denial and produce Police Reports 25‑046215 and 26‑003952, with only those portions redacted that are legitimately exempt under OPRA (e.g., specific victim identifiers or protected medical/psychiatric information); and

Provide all responsive Body Worn Camera footage from Officer Casella related to the November 9, 2025 incident, or, if you continue to deny access, identify the specific statutory exemption(s) and subsection(s) relied upon for withholding the footage.

If you maintain your denial in whole or in part, please issue a revised written response that:

Identifies each record being withheld;

Identifies the precise OPRA exemption(s) and statutory citations for each withheld record or portion; and

Advises me of my right to challenge the denial before the Government Records Council or by filing an action in the Superior Court, as required by OPRA.

Please treat this as a continuing OPRA request. Electronic delivery by email is preferred.

Sincerely,
Certified Investigative Services, LLC

My preferred delivery method for response(s) to this request is by E-mail as attachments. Please confirm you have received this request. If you are not the custodian of records, please forward my request to that person and provide their email address to me for future reference.