2024 Fatal Crash Reports and Charges Filed
Dear Woodbridge Township,
Please accept this electronic request for public records made under OPRA, Title 39, and the common law right of access. I am not required to fill out an official form or use a particular software platform to submit my request per NJSA 47:1A-6(f), which states that an email from a requestor including all of the information required on the adopted form shall suffice in place of a completed form as a valid government record request.
I HAVE NOT been convicted of any indictable offense under the laws of New Jersey, any other state, or the United States.
I WILL NOT use the requested government records for a commercial purpose.
I AM NOT seeking records in connection with a legal proceeding.
Records requested: Copies of all crash reports and criminal complaints related to fatal crashes that occurred in the year 2024 and were investigated by municipal police.
My preferred delivery method for response(s) to this request is by E-mail as attachments. Please confirm you have received this request. If you are not the custodian of records, please forward my request to that person and provide their email address to me for future reference.
Yours faithfully,
Charlie Kratovil
Good Morning,
Please see attached per your OPRA request
Thank you
Michelle LoGrande
Woodbridge Police Department
Records Bureau
One Main Street
Woodbridge, NJ 07095
PHONE (732)-602-7390
FAX (732)-726-2302
Dear Ms. LoGrande
Thanks for your response to my OPRA request. The response included five crash reports:
1/23/24 (CR-604) -- case # 24009950
2/11/24 (Convery Blvd) -- case #24017938
2/17/24 (US-1 North) -- case #24020164
3/22/24 (NJ-35) -- case #24033418
4/22/24 (Homestead Ave) -- case #24044227
Of the five reports provided, only two were from fatal crashes, according to the reports. Can you confirm whether the other three incidents (#24009950, #24017938, #24044227) were fatal or nonfatal crashes?
There is also an unexplained redaction to the fatal crash reports (cases #24020164 and #24033418). What is the reason for the redaction? Can you please provide unredacted versions per Section 4-131 of Title 39?
Also, the narrative section of the report on the fatal crash that occurred on 3/22/24 (case #24033418) states: "See Investigator Barahone's Fatal Crash Report for further detail." Please provide a copy of that report.
Finally, I believe there were several additional fatal crashes during 2024 in Woodbridge Township. I'm not sure if you were planning to send me additional reports, but please do provide any additional fatal crash reports from 2024 incidents investigated by the Woodbridge Police Department. Thanks for your assistance.
Yours sincerely,
Charlie Kratovil
Good Morning,
Redacting Government Records
Under OPRA, a government record that is otherwise publicly accessible may
contain non-disclosable information that should be redacted. Redaction
means editing a record to prevent public viewing of material that should
not be disclosed. Words, sentences, paragraphs, or whole pages may be
subject to redaction.
How to Redact
If a record contains material that must be redacted, such as a social
security number or unlisted phone number, redaction may be accomplished by
using a visually obvious method that shows the requester the specific
location of any redacted material in the record.
For example, if redacting a social security number or similar type of
small-scale redaction, custodian's should:
• Make a paper copy of the original record and manually "black out" the
information on the copy with a dark colored marker;
• Then provide a copy of the blacked-out record to the requester.
The blacked out area shows where information was redacted, while the
double copying ensures that the requester will not be able to
"see-through" to the original, non-accessible text. If "white-out"
correction fluid is used to redact material, some visual symbol should be
placed in the space formerly occupied by the redacted material to show the
location of redacted material.
If full pages are to be redacted, the custodian should give the requester
a visible indication that a particular page of that record is being
redacted, such as a blank sheet bearing the word "Page redacted" or a
written list of the specific page numbers being withheld. The purpose is
to provide formal communication to the requester making it clear that
material was not provided.
If an electronic document is subject to redaction (i.e., word processing
or Adobe Acrobat files) custodians should be sure to delete the material
being redacted. Techniques such as "hiding" text or changing its color so
it is invisible should not be used as sophisticated users can detect the
changes.
Explaining Why A Redaction is Made
When redactions are made to a record, the custodian can use either the
request form to explain why those elements of a record are redacted, or
use a separate document, depending on the circumstances, but also
referring to the OPRA exception being claimed. This principle also applies
if pages of information are redacted. Sometimes it is clear from
inspection (a entry called "Social Security Number" has a black out over
where the number would appear). The bottom line is that the requester has
a right to know the reason for the redaction, and the custodian has the
responsibility to provide a reasonable explanation.
Denying Access to Records
N.J.S.A. 47:1A-5g states that if a custodian is unable to comply with a
request for access, the custodian shall "indicate the specific basis
therefore" on the request form and promptly return it to the requester.
When a record is being withheld in its entirety, custodians must reply to
the OPRA request and explain the reason why the custodian cannot comply
with the request.
Hello,
There were only 2 fatals of the year of 2024. I just did more research.
The 2 fatals were case #24020164 & Case #24033418. I only have the crash
analysis report for case #24033418. I have attached it to this email
-Thank you
Michelle LoGrande
Woodbridge Police Department
Records Bureau
One Main Street
Woodbridge, NJ 07095
PHONE (732)-602-7390
FAX (732)-726-2302
Dear Ms. LoGrande,
Thanks for Barahona's report. I am still seeking:
1) the remaining crash reports that have not been provided
2) the reason for redactions to the NJ-TR1 reports for the fatal incidents
Here is a resource I use to find out about fatal crashes - as you can see there are several more where WPD likely investigated and filed NJ-TR1 reports. https://www.nj.gov/njsp/info/fatalacc/20... (click on Middlesex County to see the details)
Yours sincerely,
Charlie Kratovil
Good Morning,
What I sent you is all I have to give. Under OPRA we have to redact phone #'s and DOBs. That's what was blacked out.
Thank you
Good Morning,
I also clicked on the link that you provided, the fatals happened on Garden State Parkway and the turnpike. You have to contact state police for more information.
Dear Ms. LoGrande,
Regarding cases #24020164 and #24033418, can you please double check and verify what information is redacted? Based on the design of the form, I think it's the date of death, is it not?
Additionally, recognizing that some of the fatal crashed took place on the Turnpike or Parkway, I've already filed a request for those records with the NJ State Police. However, the website I shared reveals at least two additional fatal crashes that were likely investigated by WPD:
Woodbridge Twsp 10/25/2024 0905 State Highway 9
Woodbridge Twsp 10/02/2024 1735 County 514
Please check and see if these matters resulted in the creation of NJ-TR1 reports that you can provide.
Thanks for your time.
Yours sincerely,
Charlie Kratovil
Hi,
Please see attached. And yes that was the TOD. I have attached the MVA (without redactions) report and the IR with HIPPA redaction. The MVA from 10/25/2024 is not completed yet so I can't release anything.
Thank you
The Open Public Records Act (OPRA) in New Jersey excludes data protected by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) from public release.
Explanation
OPRA: A New Jersey law that gives the public more access to government records.
HIPAA: A federal law that protects the release of individually identifiable health information.
Dear Ms. LoGrande,
Thank you for the emails. I now have unredacted versions of the fatal cases from the early part of 2024. However, I asked about these two cases as well.
Woodbridge Twsp 10/25/2024 0905 State Highway 9
Woodbridge Twsp 10/02/2024 1735 County 514
You mentioned the 10/25/2024 crash is still under investigation, but what about the 10/02/2024 crash on CR-514? Can you please check for me on this one? Thanks,
Charlie Kratovil
Good Morning Mr. Kratovil,
I still do not have Ptl. Parfitt's Fatal Crash Analiysis report for MVA 24095336. I have attached the CAD for the MVA if that helps you.
Thank you again.